Pros

Skin in the Game with Abbie Schuster | Will Work for Luck

Geoff Mueller September 28, 2026

Pause and stretch. Now breathe, close your eyes, and count to fifty. While you’re at it, let’s take this quick intermission to ponder the situation: You, stumbling around the rocking bow of an 18-foot center console. You, taking in the billion-dollar views of the Vineyard’s best side, her seaside. You, slinging squid patterns into the roiling abyss. You, watching striped bass buck the rip to kill at will. You, sticking them at the rate of an overcaffeinated acupuncturist. And you, still in mental timeout of course, realizing that life – which hours earlier was a hope, prayer and handful of Advils – has for no good reason decided to do you a solid.

As chance would have it your captain for the day, striper assassin Abbie Schuster, would agree. You see, kismet – the idea of unknown forces steering untold futures toward unfathomable outcomes – has been her invisible playdate for years. So much so that Kismet is the adopted name of Schuster’s unpretentious fly shop and no-nonsense guide business. And as much as kismet implies something akin to luck, it’s weak prose for the tireless drive and bottomless enthusiasm that is Abbie.

Here’s her take on the work it takes to let it all shine in.

RIO: “Kismet” – what does it mean to you?

Abbie:
Ultimately, I think we create our own luck – and circumstances generally fall into place with the help of a lot of hard work. On the other side of the spectrum is this feeling that here I am doing exactly what I should be doing. And I'm so grateful that this is what I get to do every day… everything in my life has really built up to this moment, learning to fly fish on Martha's Vineyard, going to school out West, learning to guide and then realizing I could do all of this on my own.

But definitely, you put luck into your own hands. And you have to commit.

RIO: Talk us through your fly-fishing beginnings.

Abbie:
I've always loved fly fishing. My dad taught me when I was casting from his shoulders because I was too small to wade. On my birthdays, we always went fishing because it's in October, which was a perfect time to hit Long Island Sound or come out here and visit my grandmother on Martha’s Vineyard.

During my freshman year at the University of Vermont, I traveled out West for the first time to visit a friend in Montana. I was so blown away by what I saw that I applied to UM in the airport on the way home… and got in. Then I had to break the news to my parents. I took them out to dinner, which like had never happened because I was a poor college kid at the time, and I told them I was moving to Montana and to be a fly-fishing guide.

My dad was so stoked. My mom was like, what the actual f--k. Of course it was a risk. I didn't really know many people, and I’d only spent like 48 hours in the whole western United States. But I had absolutely fallen in love with it. I mean come on – the Clark Fork River running right through campus – are you kidding me?

Alongside college classes, I enrolled in Sweetwater Travel’s guide school. I was this small 20-year-old blonde girl from the East Coast and was not taken super seriously. Not shocking. I wouldn’t have taken me seriously either. But I learned a lot in terms of what it meant to actually be a guide. And from there I started working for a few local fly shops, running tills and rowing trips.

RIO: What barriers did you face?

Abbie:
It was tough in the beginning. After Montana, I was in Seattle and Alaska and I was young, which didn’t help. There weren’t a ton of women guides at the time. And that still stands true. Everything I did felt like it was under a microscope. It still sometimes feels that way. People are waiting for you to fail. And there’s a lot of nitpicking.

That was the biggest challenge – having everything questioned all the time. I had to prove myself over and over again, in ways I don’t think male guides typically have to. But it motivated me to be the best at this craft. To know my shit and make sure it’s dialed. It pushed me to work harder to prove myself. I do love to prove a point!

RIO: Biggest supporters and cheerleaders over the years?

Abbie:
I’m thankful to have a strong, supportive family. Their motto has always been make mistakes, sure, but you better learn from them. And if you keep making the same mistake… well, maybe there’s a serious problem there.

RIO: Alaska to Seattle… you’ve made some big moves.

Abbie:
Alaska, yes. I was based in Homer, working on a salmon and halibut charter boat, living in a VW van on the spit. The first thing my captain, Jim Craddock, asked when I showed up at the dock was whether I got seasick. Of course told him, ‘No way.' We went 38 miles offshore that day, straight into churning ten-foot seas. To this day, I don’t think I’ve ever been sicker in my life. I was practically hallucinating. And I was pretty sure I was getting fired. But for some reason he still calls me every year to see if I wanna come back to work.

Learning how to navigate the ocean and how to problem-solve on boats, for that I’m forever grateful. After that, I went back to Montana and guided for Glacier Anglers & Outfitters on the Middle Fork of the Flathead. I also worked briefly at Montana Angler Fly Fishing in Bozeman which gave me the opportunity to learn the ins and outs of retail and managing a team of guides.

Then I moved to Seattle to work with Dave McCoy at Emerald Waters Anglers, where he was looking to build a women’s program at the time. Dave is like the whackiest, best human ever. And he fully believed in me. I think by day three I was already booked on a trip. Our energies matched perfectly and we had some fun.

Dave McCoy, on the early days:

Abbie played an integral part in building EWA from its early beginnings to what it is today. Starting back in 2013, when the shop was still somewhat of a napkin sketch, we knew we wanted a women’s program which, as you’d imagine, required a woman to run it.

I remember driving in the car one day, scrolling through emails in the passenger seat and no shit, there was a message from someone named Abbie, asking about a job. So that’s kinda how it all started
– happenstance. What I didn’t know at the time was the potency of her enigmatic energy and the infectiousness of her enthusiasm for everything.

Whether it was spearheading the women’s curriculum, learning how to guide the Yak, or painting a third of our original store, Abbie rolled up her sleeves and crushed it. To this day I consider her like a surrogate daughter. To have her story ingrained in this sport and our history benefits us all. I’m beyond proud of her.


RIO: Why’d you part ways with Seattle?

Abbie:
Honestly, I hit a point where I could no longer ignore what I was missing on the East Coast. After seeing a lot of the country, I felt in my heart that Martha’s Vineyard offered some of the best fishing anywhere. I’ve just always been obsessed with it.

I was 26, didn’t have kids, wasn’t yet married, and I missed home and my family – especially my striped bass. It’s been the best decision I’ve ever made.

RIO: East bound and down. What was the hardest part about moving back?

Abbie:
Remembering just how much you must respect the ocean when you’re out there fishing hard and running boats in challenging conditions. I had to hone in on running boats again, which I did with help from my husband, Justin, and by going back to the skills I’d picked up in Alaska.

I knew the fishery enough from growing up here but I had to become a student of the ocean and the boat and soak in every second of every day – learning by full immersion. The first year I only took shore trips while I was working toward my captain’s license, which I got in 2016.

RIO: You cracked open the Kismet shop around that same time?

Abbie:
The first step was laying down the foundation for guiding, which took every part of me. Two years into it, I recognized that there was a void – especially in and around Martha’s Vineyard – that could be filled with a fly shop.

I was so sick of going into other shops and being treated like I didn’t know what I was doing. There’s no need for that. We’re not doing brain surgery – we’re just out here trying to catch fish. At the time, my entire income was also dependent on whatever Mother Nature had in store for me. Having an additional, steady source of income from the fly shop really helps round out the whole business model.

RIO: How do you balance it all?

Abbie:
Ha. It’s like juggling a tornado. But it’s a good tornado because I’m better and more grounded when I have a lot going on. So, I think that what we’ve created really suits my personality well. I’m also lucky I have the employees I have at Kismet because they really bring so much to the balancing act. They truly care about the job, this fishery, the clients and this community that Kismet has helped create.

RIO: Tell us about your vision for Kismet?

Abbie:
It all goes back to creating community and bringing new anglers into the fold. I never want the shop to feel intimidating. We have the best fly fishing gear, but you can also pick up something to read, find some great logo wear, or just browse – whatever. Not everything has to be strictly about fly fishing. Over the years, a lot of those non-anglers have become lifelong clients.

Another important element is conservation. One thing every Kismet client leaves with is a better understanding of how their voice is important in influencing smart management decisions.

We have the privilege to fish these waters, which means we have an obligation to protect them. Striper are good to eat, sure, but they’re so much more valuable when kept in the water. I want every Kismet client to come away with a better understanding of our fishery. When they experience it firsthand – in the boat, breathing in the salt, engaging with nature – it’s hard to ignore the importance of what we’re trying to sustain.

RIO: What fires you up about the fishery?

Abbie: For me it’s the variety of the species we get to target and the unpredictable nature of the conditions – over the course of a day or week or season. Every day is different. Which makes burnout a nonreality. June is the squid migration, which is my favorite. It’s so visual. And it makes for some great flats fishing opportunities for stripers.

By mid-summer, when it’s traditionally tougher fishing, our flats continue to produce. The bluefish also arrive around that time, and we’re looking for blitzing fish under diving birds. It’s always evolving, which makes it always exciting. So much of our fishery is so visual and it’s awesome getting to share that with some really cool people.

Honestly though, what gets me the most excited is a no-wind forecast. If the wind lays down we’re having a great day!

RIO: Chappaquiddick, aka Chappy? Tell us about your home island.

Abbie:
Chappy definitely attracts a certain person. There’s one store. It’s not open often. And big Chappy news is when someone gets a new lawnmower. But there are a lot of young entrepreneurs on the island, which is great. The best thing about living on a tiny island, located just off another island, is you end up becoming really close as a community. It’s a place where nobody leaves doors locked. And if you need some milk in the middle of the night, like when your baby’s kicking and screaming, you can just break into the neighbor’s place and pilfer their fridge. Not that I’d ever done that. Ha!

RIO: We know you’re a yoga pro. Tell us why more anglers should take it up?

Abbie:
Yoga chills me out – and I’m not a chill person at all, so that’s good for me. Standing on a boat all day can put a lot of stress on the body. From just a physical-strength standpoint it’s been amazing.

It’s also important for anyone to be able to breathe and see a situation for what it is. To be able to take a breath and react, like when albies are streaming in at 40 mhp, or when stripers are blitzing and you’ve got a split-second 60-foot shot to make. For me that all ties back to yoga. Working through a hard pose or a tough situation and then being able to maintain your composure goes a long way anywhere in life.

RIO: What does having “skin the game” mean to you?

Abbie:
If you’re going to do anything in life you need to fully commit. We’re fortunate to be on the water, immersed in nature, doing what we love. So, it’s important we’re here for each other, showing up when it counts. Whether that’s fighting as hard as you can for conservation or figuring out ways to adapt in sustainable ways – you have to be willing to grow and learn and grind. It’s never going to be easy, but when you put in the work it’s always going to be rewarding.

RIO: What RIO lines are you fishing these days, and why?

Abbie:
Our fishery is amazing because it encompasses many fisheries in one. One day we fish rips and flats and the lines we use need to keep up. RIO Striper lines recalibrate well to all our situations. A good striper line works well within a wide temperature range, plus it needs to have the ability to huck big squid flies into the rips but be soft enough to cast to spooky 40-inch bass in a foot of water.

At the start of the season, fish become active when the water hits 55 degrees. By late summer and fall our waters climb to 80. The RIO Blitz line is one of my faves because it’ll cast into the wind with little effort and easily handles big flies. It also has a short 26-ft head that shoots line exceptionally well. Hardtails don't fool around, so you need to cast quickly before they’re long gone. The Blitz makes shooting line easy, giving anglers a better opportunity to hook up with amazing, strong fish that will make you good friends with your backing.